Monday, September 29, 2014

My Depression Quest

TRIGGER WARNING: Discussion of depression


---

It’s your first day of high school. Coming off the back of a cliquey class of 26 in a Catholic grade school, you feel unsure about your future friendships, that is, if you’ll even have any in this new environment. Your regard your friendships in grade school as worthwhile but in some cases fair-weather or limited. You didn’t seem to fully fit within any group at that school, yet most of them accepted you at one point or another. And like all middle-schoolers, you didn’t really know who you were at the time.


Now you do, or, at least you have a pretty good idea. In the beginning of eighth grade, you met some really cool people from the blogging and forum-posting community of a popular video game news website, and it turns out you totally can forge meaningful, lasting friendships over the Internet. Those “weirdos,” as you sister calls them, besides making you laugh and talking to you about video games, made you mature and realize what kinds of things you care about and the kinds of things you like to see in people. But how to “sell” yourself, your personality, to strangers in the “real” world. Do you even want to do that?


It’s dark at 6:15 a.m. in September, as you wait on the corner of your bus stop. Out of the fog comes the bus, hissing and roaring its way up the street. You hop in and find that the bus is nearly empty except for one girl in the middle. You slowly make your way down the aisle, and as the driver puts on the gas, you nearly fall into seat 11.


You’re practically shaking in your seat, creeped out by the darkness and the musty smell of the bus. You consider saying hello to the girl, just one seat in front of you and across the aisle, but maybe she doesn’t want to be bothered…


What do you do?

Introduce yourself.
Wait for more people to get on the bus and try talk to them.
Put your iPod on, and stare out the window.

*click*


You look around you, an old Muse song buzzing in your ear, the bus filling with bodies and noise. You glance at each kid as they board the bus before quickly shifting your gaze back out the window. You hear slurs from the back of the bus and giggles from the front. In the middle where you are, most are either sleeping or quietly staring. You’re feeling very tense and uncertain.


After 45 minutes you arrive at the school. Your bus is the first to make it. A group of upperclassmen are outside welcoming the freshmen. Your neighbor who’s a senior offers you and the kids cookies. Obligingly, you take one, even though you’re uncomfortable eating around strangers. The cookie is like a puck anyway.


The kids from your bus are filed into the gym for a welcoming before homeroom and classes. But your bus is a good 50 minutes early, so you’ll be waiting for a long time, even for another bus to show up. A group including someone from your grade school to whom you’re ambivalent decides to sit on the bleachers, while a few outliers, including another grade school classmate, drift near the entrance.

Time to meet new people. Join the group on the bleachers.
Say hi to your classmate near the entrance.
Pretend to use your phone.

*click*


You scroll through your contacts, finding nobody you normally text except your mom, dad, and sister.


“Hi, Dan!”  


“Oh! Hi.”


Your friend from grade school says some random things about starting high school and laughs obnoxiously. But you just kind of smile and shrug him off, not knowing what to say.


You go back to pretending to text people, feeling really awkward and transparent.


“Hey, no phones out in school.”


You immediately tense up. It’s your other grade school classmate calling from the bleachers, with everybody watching. Your heart starts to beat fast. Why do you have to be put on the spot?


“Who are you texting?”


“Just… a friend.”


“Why don’t you come sit with us?” 

You head over ready to make some friends.
Out of obligation, you make your way to the bleachers.
You politely decline the invitation.

*click*


You hesitate. You know you’re not going to be able to talk to these people; they’re talking about celebrities, rap music, and sports, which you know nothing about. You start to say that you’re fine where you are, but you realize that’s pretty rude and head over.


Your classmate’s friends introduce themselves and ask you a series of questions. They keep telling you to speak up, but you’re too nervous of saying the wrong things. You eventually compare rosters with everyone, and you don’t have classes with any of the guys in the group but two with one of the girls.


You sit in silence as the gym finally fills up with more freshmen, some of whom sit with the group around you. As noise fills the gym, you feel your face getting hot, wishing you could just turn invisible. You feel sweaty and like you might throw up, but no one’s even talking to you.


You sit through the welcoming in extreme discomfort, and afterwards walk to homeroom in an anxious haze. The rest of your day is better; you meet some nice people in your classes, including your lab partners for biology and the girl who sits in front of you in homeroom. But once you get home, pressures from many different places hit you. How exactly are you supposed to go about this high school thing? You’ve been hounded by your mom all your life about homework and grades (an extension of the guilt of her mistakes in life), so you’ve developed this perfectionism involving schoolwork. But you also want to be liked and have fun with friends in school. And you especially want to take care of yourself, enjoy your hobbies and the friendships you already have both online and off.


You’re being flung into high school with a lot of expectations put on you and your experience. They say to get good grades so you get into college and get a job and don’t die. “You’ll do great!” and all. They also say to enjoy the best and easiest four years of your life.


How do you spend that first one?

Talk to anyone and everyone. Get involved around the school and hang out with your classmates. Schoolwork is an afterthought.
After meeting some cool people in class, balance schoolwork and friends.
Spend a lot of time relaxing at home, playing video games, chatting with your online friends.
Stress about your schoolwork. You must get nearly perfect grades.

*click*


You do really well. You get high 90’s on almost every test. Your lowest grade for a marking period was a 92 in biology. Teachers commend your work but wish you would participate more.


You also hate life.


Your focus on school not only prevents you from meeting new people, but also prevents you from spending time on your already developed hobbies. You live in a constant state of terror in which you panic every time you’re assigned a new project, lab report, or paper. Your work must be perfect, so you spend far too much time on it than necessary. The workload itself isn’t that much, but you swamp yourself by agonizing over it. Your stress is compounded by your mom’s constant pressure to get certain numbers on report cards and to stop being so lazy.


You’re assigned a five-page short story due by the end of the week. You have no idea what you’re going to write about.

Hunker down and get to brainstorming. You’ll finish the draft in no time.
Think about every word you put down, every story detail. You want your first draft to be phenomenal.
You’re stressed, so just wind down for a bit. Take a nap, and then you’ll be able to work.

*click*


You get maybe a paragraph written an hour. You start with an idea in your head and quickly reject it. After a half an hour you come up with a story detail you like but take another half an hour to put it into words. You lie on your back in between phrases to stare at the wall for ten minutes at a time. At dinner, your mom asks you how you’re coming along with the paper. You can’t even find the strength to respond, feeling panicky and useless. She starts to get upset and tells you to get back to work right after dinner.


Eventually, it gets too late to finish the draft, but later in the week you get it done to your relief. You hand it in and get and excellent grade. But you don’t think the number was worth what you did to yourself.


This sequence becomes more and more common as you’re given assignments throughout the year. You end up stressing about your work for far longer time periods than actually working, usually while staring at the ceiling or burying your face in the pillow. You also find it increasingly difficult to interact with anyone. Every time your family tries to talk to you, you either don’t respond or get unreasonably mad and flee to your room. And while you enjoy your friends from grade school who sit with you at lunch, as well as some new friends from the tennis team, it’s hard to really connect to people. You feel distanced from others and from your own emotions. You beg your mom to let you skip school every single day, but you end up getting perfect attendance at the end of the year.


You feel worthless most of the time. You tell yourself you could never be successful and never add anything to the world because you’re so slow to work, lazy, and unsociable. Many times you just want to lie down in bed and never wake up again. You don’t believe it’s worth living in this world. You feel extremely guilty about these thoughts because you know your family loves you and that there are people who have it so much worse than you. That just makes you feel worse yourself.

Explain these thoughts to your therapist.
Explain these thoughts to your parents.
Explain these thoughts to an online friend.
Keep these thoughts bottled up inside you.

*click*


The comfort of being behind a keyboard to gather your thoughts before communicating lets you open up to an online friend about your struggles in school. Though you have trouble explaining everything to him, especially your more darker thoughts, he listens with compassion. You feel a little better every time you talk to him because he responds with empathy and patience towards your venting.


Your therapist has also been trying to help you. You’ve gone to him on and off since you were six years old for behavioral and sleeping problems. He’s a great person and therapist, who recommends you all the right things to calm you down, even if your anxiety is too much at this point for those tips to have long-term impact. But when it comes to adults, you struggle to mention the worst because you’re afraid of not being taken seriously--that you’re just an angsty kid going through a phase, that it will all just go away with age. You don’t exactly believe this to be what your therapist would say to you as a professional, but for some reason you can’t get that fear out of your head. You’re also scared of medication.


---


Fast forward to February of junior year. Many things have changed. You’ve learned to control your emotions for the most part. You realize anxiety disorder and depression run on both sides of the family, so you’ll likely be dealing with it in some capacity forever as a hereditary part of your brain chemistry. Researching anxiety and depression has helped you understand yourself a little more and how to minimize their control over you. But you still get into demoralizing funks sometimes. You still freak out about schoolwork, and this year has proven to be the most challenging yet. But therapy has helped both you and your mother, so neither yourself nor she hounds on you nearly as much. Your confidence to participate in class and speak your mind has also risen. Just last week you wrote a risky, provocative essay for AP English that got you positive comments from all your classmates and your best grade of the class.


You also have good friends in school now. They have been trying to get you to go to the weekly meetings for the literary magazine for weeks, but you’ve been busy, without a ride home, or just not interested in going. You promised them you would go this week, but you inexplicably feel terrible in the middle of eighth period. You have a lot of homework. You’re tired. You want to go to this meeting, but you suddenly just feel nervous and sick.


The bell rings. You meet your friend in the hall, and he asks if you’re headed to the classroom where the meeting’s held.

Cheer up. You won’t let this random emptiness stop you from enjoying an afternoon with your friends. Tell him of course you’re going.
Tell him you’re going to the meeting even though you’re anxious. You don’t want to let your friends down.
Tell him you don’t feel good, so you’re just going to head home.

*click*


Your friend is really disappointed you can’t make it and tells you to feel better. You thank him and get on the bus.


You’re upset you had to ditch your friends again, but your need to go home reminds you of something you’ve wanted to do for a while. Apparently, a few weeks ago this game called Depression Quest came out. You initially thought the game was some indie dungeon crawler with title referring to some esoteric mechanic rather than the illness. That’s just your expectation of games right now. But you read that the game actually portrays depression, the kind you’re familiar with. You read nothing but positive remarks from journalists and critics on the game, about how it could help sufferers with depression realize they’re not alone and friends and families of sufferers better understand depression. Tonight, reading a little more about it, you learn it’s free and short. You’ve got another hour until dinner, so you decide to play it.


You breath deepens and slows at the game’s first piano chord. You play as a character pretty different from you. You’re not in the so-called “real world” of adult life, searching for a fulfilling job. You’ve never had a significant other. But all the same feelings are there. You decide to answer the prompts as you would in your freshmen-year mindset.


In the game, you feel too anxious to go out to a party with your girlfriend. You’re reluctant to talk to your parents and friends about your feelings. You can’t make an appointment with a therapist because you’re too afraid to use the phone. The character shows many of the same emotions/symptoms you’ve had: wanting life to be good but lacking motivation, being too exhausted to focus, self-hate for being unproductive, shame for these feelings. The game starts limiting your choices based on your level of depression, using a red line to cross out options that your character just can’t find the strength to do. Those options remain readable, meaning that the character knows that the healthier choices are available but just can’t do them, something you haven’t thought about much but definitely matches your experience. You end up taking the character down a dark path that gets progressively worse.


At one point, you just start crying. And crying. You realize that the reason you’ve come so far with your depression--the reason you haven’t gone down the spiral your character in Depression Quest has--is the people in your lives who care about you. You wouldn’t have gotten better if your mom didn’t love you enough to get help for the both of you. You wouldn’t have gotten better without people like your sister and your online friends you could reach out to. You’re feel so privileged to have the people around you. You wish others could have the same support network as yourself. You’re still sad at the fact that others have it worse. You’re sad that your character finds himself seemingly defeated by depression at the end of the game.


But you feel better about yourself for eventually having had the strength to talk to people.


You feel like you can do anything, like you can get even further away from your anxiety controlling your life.  


---


College is right around the corner. You’re super nervous. You don’t know if you’ll have issues living on your own or if the work will be too much.


But mostly you’re afraid of a repeat of freshmen year in high school.


You know you’re much better now with people, with yourself. But you can’t help fearing a big change like this might make you dig yourself back into that nightmarish hole.


Soon enough, it’s opening weekend on campus, and so far you’re doing okay even if you’re a little uncomfortable. Your roommate’s really nice, but you haven’t met any close friends yet.


You open your suite’s door Sunday morning and find a crowd of people on your floor’s lounge, some of whom you met briefly throughout the programs of the weekend. You want to involve yourself, but you have some reading to do for your first class on Tuesday. You could also be playing a game or maybe start a blog you’ve been thinking about for a while. Oh, and you’re unsure if you’ll say a word if you go in the lounge.


What do you do?

Head out to the lounge and try to talk to people.
Finish the book for class.
Start playing Knights of the Old Republic
Stay in your room and stare at the wall.

*click*


You quietly introduce yourself to the group and climb into a chair. You’re curt and anxious the whole time, and everyone comments on how quiet you are.


But you end up staying in the lounge for five hours, and you slowly but surely come out of your shell. Your RA pulls out a Wii and Super Smash Bros. Brawl, and suddenly you feel pretty great.


Before you know it, you’re a month into college. You’re friends with pretty much all the freshmen on your floor. You have movie nights in the lounge, play cards and games a lot, explore downtown, and meet for lunch and dinner at the dining halls every day. You’ve only been here a month and you feel that some of your friends are closer to you than people you’ve known for a decade.


Sometimes you just have those days when you’re a bit overwhelmed with work, trying new things, meeting new people, and that looming “real world” that you’ll be faced with in a few short years. But for every instance of anxiety there’s about ten moments of joy. You feel more confident than you ever have.


You’ve come to a point where you feel pretty comfortable with talking about your time in high school and have a lot you want to express so you can fully move on from your painful experiences. You find an opportunity in a blog post to write about the past four years. But you’re unsure if you really want to go through with writing or publishing it. You might not have the time to write, and publishing this personal stuff seems sort of self-indulgent to you.

Put the post up. You’ll finally get some closure for yourself.
Write the post, but save it for yourself. Why should other people care about your past issues?
Maybe put it on the backburner. High school wasn’t that long ago, so maybe give yourself some more distance from it first.
Don’t bother. Your writing’s shit and no one will read it anyway. It won’t even really help you.

*click*


---


This blog post was written for Critical Distance’s Blogs of the Round Table August-September Topic on cathartic experiences with video games.  

Monday, July 28, 2014

My Sword and My Shield

Oh my god, where IS she?


I’ve been waiting at the entrance to this cave for about five minutes. The orchestral strings slowly swell and recede as I pan my view across the bluffs, paths, and hilltops barely visible in the blinding snowstorm. I’m starting to get anxious. Am I really going to have a reload a save from twenty minutes ago again? Then finally, a blurry figure appears over the hill, sprinting down the slope. As it approaches, crunching footfalls get louder with every step. A familiar face appears under a Forsworn headdress I gifted. Phew. There she is.


Lydia.


“Hey, look, a cave! I wonder what’s inside.”


---




The companion AI in The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim is notoriously awful. If you decide to sprint through any tough terrain, or sprint at all, you run the risk of losing your partner, momentarily or forever. She may be determinedly running into a bush, unable to decide how to go about moving the twenty feet to where you are, as you imagine your character impatiently tapping his foot, arms crossed. She might decide not to risk a two foot drop and take the long, long way around a main path, and before she reaches you she might get attacked by an ice troll. Traversing Skyrim with a follower means stopping and turning around every few seconds to make sure your partner catches up with you. It feels like what I imagine escorting a toddler through a zoo or shopping mall must be like. And I don’t think I want to be a parent.


Companions really slow down your progress in Skyrim. I attribute my having played Skyrim for 128 hours and having only finished the main quest, the Daedric quests, and the College of Winterhold questline, while many other players finish most or all major questlines in that time, to Lydia’s curious and frustrating behavior. So why did I play so much of the game with a companion that made exploring the wintry landscapes of Skyrim actively worse in most cases? I tolerated Lydia blocking narrow passages in dungeons and making me grunt at the TV, “Lydia, MOVE!” because she became part of my adventure, my story, and I soon found that I couldn’t finish the game without her.


---


Of the many characters who offered to follow me on my adventure through Skyrim, I chose Lydia to accompany me because she was probably the first person in the game I felt I could trust. She was assigned to be my housecarl after I was titled Thane of Whiterun for defeating my first dragon in the fields outside the town. Though a patriotic Nord (whereas I was an outsider Argonian), she seemed above the shady politics of Skyrim’s civil war, simply ready to serve as my trusty housecarl. She looked tough and capable with her steel armor and had a pleasant voice with an air of genuine righteousness. I figured it would be a depressing existence for a dedicated housecarl to sit in town while I was out adventuring. So I asked her to follow me, and off we went into the harsh wilderness.






Lydia proved to be both frustrating and useful, and I quickly grew attached to her quirks. She was a fearless warrior, rushing to my defense against bandits, giants, and Falmer, without regarding the safety of her own life. She almost got herself killed multiple times charging at enemies from high drops (of course she’ll run off cliffs in combat but won’t climb over a hill while exploring). And she often sent her arrows too early, foiling my attempts at sneaking. Lydia always managed to stand her ground, though, and fend off a bear by herself while I was preoccupied by a troll.


But certain enemies were too much for Lydia. She was knocked down by giants, mammoths, and some late-game bandits. But her one true fear, her one kryptonite, left Lydia vulnerable and frightened every time we encountered them: stationary boulders. There are traps in many of Skyrim’s dungeons, and most frequently in Draugr tombs, a group of shin-high boulders will roll down a slope after you when you trigger the trap by stepping on a panel. After easily dodging the rocks, they will rest at the bottom of the slope for you to walk over/around them. I did so, expecting Lydia to follow behind. But instead I heard the typical “ow” and “ugh” of Lydia being attacked, so I figured a Draugr must have been following us or got trapped in geometry until now. When I turned around, I saw Lydia repeated run into the short boulders and recoil from damage. You could tell she was getting frustrated. She was yelling, “Damn you!” at the boulders, and I was laughing. But when I approached, her health bar appeared and showed a sliver of health left. She hit her shin on a rock one more time and fell to her knee. I mashed buttons as quick as a could to equip the Grand Healing spell to revive her.


“A healing spell! Are you a--”


LYDIA, DON’T YOU EVER SCARE ME LIKE THAT AGAIN.


With Lydia, a small annoyance could become a grave danger, and I guess that’s what made having her around fun.


But Lydia was genuinely charming and interesting in her own right. Though she simultaneously endeared and annoyed me with recycled dialogue of “I am sworn to protect you” and “Honor to see you, my Thane,” she was steadfast to her principles. I could typically instruct her to stand somewhere or attack something, but when I pointed at citizens and non-hostiles to assault, she always said something to effect of, “I would never do that!” Yet she remained loyal to me throughout it all, never bothered by the request, or my occasional unsolicited violence against town guards, or later in the game, my cannibalism. She never told the authorities about my behavior, but she probably wanted to... I always wondered what Lydia thought of me; my character was exceptionally creepy. Perhaps she simply learned not to judge those in authority and to instead remain faithful to her duties as housecarl.


But it was apparent that she thought something of me. I went through a phase playing Skyrim in which I would collect all the books I found, planning to store them in my home to read some day. Of course, these books were too heavy to keep in my inventory while exploring, so I simply gave them to Lydia to hold. Her exasperated tone when she remarked, “I am sworn to carry your burdens,” every time I dropped books in her pocket meant that she knew I would never read them and was just wasting our time and inventory space.


Lydia also seemed to have some secret desires and interests. Even though she was trained to be a warrior, she seemed to enjoy using magic when given the opportunity. Though her primary weapons were the glass battleaxe I gave her and her standard bow, she would often pull out the magic staffs I would have her carry for me. She loved resurrecting wolves and shooting lightning at spiders, and I had to remember to recharge those staffs with soul gems regularly. I imagine that growing up as a Nord, Lydia’s parents shunned the idea of magic, but maybe she was always drawn to it. And I finally gave her the tools to explore a long-forbidden obsession with sorcery and necromancy.


The beauty of companion characters like Lydia is that they have just enough personality to be endearing but are also empty husks, allowing the player’s imagination to fill in the rest of the characters’ history and traits. When Skyrim first released, players talked about their experiences of “emergent gameplay,” all of the funny or cool things they saw or did that not everyone does, including epic battles between dragons and giants, goofy glitches of mammoths falling out of the sky, and pedestrian tasks of trying to properly set a table, cook a meal, and serve the food. These moments make every player’s story in Skyrim just a little different. But the random nature of Skyrim’s world alone doesn’t make our stories personal. How we frame events, decisions, and characters in our own created context, whether our imaginations be playful, serious, or cruel, allows us to co-author our (mis)adventures.


Lydia became an integral part of my adventure, but before I realized that, I tried to get rid of her. I was so frustrated by her consistently bad AI, and after losing her twice in the icy waters above Winterhold (forcing me to reload), I decided to send her back to my Breezehome residence in Whiterun. I felt liberated. I sprinted across the terrain, defying physics on steep inclines and jumping over rocky cliffs without having to worry about separating from my follower or having herself get killed. I could focus on the game’s lovely atmosphere and environments. But, something was missing… 




There was no one to say, “I’ve got a bad feeling about this,” when I approached obviously dangerous areas, like when I entered the Draugr catacombs. As I went through the dungeon, the totally not-scary Draugr sent shivers up my spine every time they aggro’d with that creepy cough as they climbed out of their tombs. These low to high level enemies ganged up on me, freaking me out a little too much with their crazy blue eyes. So I ran the hell out of there before I died and back out the entrance. Looks like I needed Lydia after all.


For all of her silly actions and sayings, Lydia is at her best when she echoes the wonderment of discovery in exploring Skyrim.


“I have never seen anything quite like that.”


Lydia, we cleared out this Dwemer ruin last week.


“I am your sword and your shield.”


*rolls eyes* Oh, Lydia.


---

This blog post was written for Critical Distance’s Blogs of the Round Table June-July Topic  on memorable experiences with non-playable characters.

Wednesday, July 23, 2014

The Average Emiles of War

There are many video games about war, and most have similar elements. How controversial to say, right? Obviously most war games, including both those that treat the subject carefully and not, involve the player shooting a lot of people. But also, nearly all of these games have characters with the same status in society. They’re all career soldiers thrown into combat with experience. Some, such as Captain Walker of Spec Ops: The Line and Commander Shepard of Mass Effect (yes, we are going to call that series “war games”), have chosen to enlist in the military to serve their respective country/political entity or for some other, perhaps unexplained, reason. Others, like Solid Snake of Metal Gear Solid and Nomad of Crysis, are specifically raised, even manufactured, to be the perfect soldier.






In stories dominated by military jargon and political melodrama, players are put into perspectives separate from “regular” civilian lives. If a personal conflict is portrayed in a war game, it usually regards the toll of combat on a character’s mental and physical health or relationships between other soldiers and military figures. Even though these protagonists and supporting characters might make a passing reference to a spouse and kids, players primarily observe them as members of a military before members of a family. They may be developed with an emotional depth and range and appear to behave as believable human beings, but they are consistently portrayed as exotic compared to everyday citizens.

By portraying soldiers primarily as combat experts and potential heroes, games create a divide in their worlds between those soldiers set to save the world, galaxy, whatever and civilians cheering or suffering on the sidelines. This dichotomy perhaps reflects the modern all-volunteer militaries of many western countries. The US military has been active in conflicts around the world in recent years, but civilians haven’t been conscripted to the service since 1973, during the Vietnam War. The characters in video games about war echo the soldiers of our time: freely choosing to enlist for practical or ideological reasons, perhaps being a part of a family with a history in the military. So video games, often so wrapped up in the high-stakes action of combat and politics of war, rarely explore how people ambivalent or opposed to conflicts are swept up in them.

Putting soldiers on a level different from “normal people” plays into the common nature of games as power fantasies as well. In a typical war game, players can assume the role of essentially a superhuman: a soldier capable of defeating waves of enemies to resolve an intensified crisis vaguely similar to what western players might hear on the news but never come close to experiencing. In most cases, this soldier is disconnected from pedestrian thoughts and actions, aside from briefly grieving a lost comrade or once mentioning a longing for home. Though it may be farfetched to say that many people will interpret the action and stories in these games as realistic depictions of war, I wonder if civilian players can internalize the idea that “there are soldiers and then there are us” through these games. That’s not exactly a great mindset in a society that wants to eradicate war and one that already struggles helping soldiers adjust to civilian life after combat.

One game travels back a hundred years, to a war in which civilians were drafted, to show that soldiers are indeed one of us.

Ubisoft Montpellier’s Valiant Hearts: The Great War opens in the French countryside in 1914. After the outbreak of the war, Karl, a German citizen and farmer, is separated from his French wife and their son after being expelled from the country and forced to fight for Germany. Soon after, Karl’s father-in-law Emile is called to join the war effort for France. Meanwhile, Anna, a young Belgian woman studying to become a veterinarian, goes on a journey to find her father who the Germans had captured to exploit his scientific research to create new weapons. She decides to use her healing gifts to nurse all those in need along the way, regardless of uniform. Emile soon meets Freddie, an American who willfully enlists in the French army to avenge his wife fallen to a German bomb. 


The player switches between these characters throughout the game to solve 2D point-and-click style puzzles. These characters are ordinary people disturbed by this conflict and thrown into it, and even though Freddie’s story follows a tired trope, he eventually learns his hunger for revenge is not worth the cost of war. Valiant Hearts is little interested in the international politics of World War I and rather focuses on the war’s effects on individuals and groups of people. With these simple characters trying to outlive the war in order to reunite with their displaced families, the game posits that there are no good guys or bad guys in war, just victims of a political climate beyond their control. (At the same time, though, Valiant Hearts is awkwardly allies-normative, betraying its message by pitting the heroes against an evil caricature of a German baron for much of the game.)

Valiant Hearts’ gameplay focuses on environmental puzzles that often require players to find items to repair machinery, trade with NPCs, or blow open new paths with explosives in order to progress. The little direct violence in Valiant Hearts involves a sequence shooting down enemy planes from a tank and the occasional knocking of opposing soldiers over the head during stealth. There are also a few light-hearted sequences in which the player drives a taxi while avoiding obstacles and bombs in time to “Flight of the Bumblebee” and other classical pieces of music. And the story takes its liberties separating and bringing the characters back together over an enormous battlefield and conveniently saving characters from imminent death. No, Valiant Hearts is by no stretch a “realistic” depiction of combat or the events of World War I. But it doesn’t have to be.

The elements of the game that resemble a Saturday morning cartoon, including its cutesy art and whimsical segments, while occasionally jarring (e.g. the baron), more often endear players to the characters, making the story’s many crushing moments of loss and hellish images of corpses and destruction more impactful. The player yearns for more infectiously  gleeful moments during the disheartening and tense ones that are inevitable in war. The urgency of battle scenes in which you charge amidst artillery fire particularly stand in stark contrast to the giddy taxicab sequences. Unlike many other pieces of war media that drown in their tension, horror, and nihilism, Valiant Hearts’ lighter side recalls the positive emotions of a joyful world to be cherished, a world that war does a terrible job protecting. 



While the game’s cartoonish depiction of WWI plays loose with details to demonstrate the war’s toll on its fictional characters, Valiant Hearts’ excellent system of collectibles and historical facts reminds players that this was a real conflict that affected real people. At the start of every level, the game provides optional historical tidbits to read accompanied by photographs in its menu, often about the location of the level, the event that took place there, and different aspects of combat and civilian life during the war. The game provides short accessible descriptions of tunnel digging strategies, living conditions, dog tag systems, and occasional statistics through these facts. Throughout the levels, players can find items that when examined in the menu, give even more information on their uses or the events and people associated with them. Players can pick up a rag to learn about soldiers covering their faces in urine-soaked rags to protect themselves from chlorine gas and a metal cross to learn about the importance of religion to many during the war. The most powerful moments of the game occur when players connect the trauma of the individual characters to the realization that those characters aren’t alone in their struggles. Through the game’s mini history lessons, players see that the war affected millions of people, not just soldiers but the entire European society and many other parts of the world. The facts acknowledge the contributions and sacrifices of Indian soldiers, all-black regiments, women joining the workforce, women tasked with writing letters to soldiers without families, prisoners of war, and of course those hopelessly adorable dogs of war. 



A lot of people have noted that Valiant Hearts breaks the mould as a war game that doesn’t focus on shooting, where the player’s actions are more often benevolent than harmful. But I’m more interested in that Valiant Hearts recognizes and commits to showing that many different ordinary people participate in war and are affected by it. So why can’t war games set in modern times in conflicts fictional or otherwise do the same? Though the world’s conflicts today are largely without drafts and not on the scale of World War I, the military personnel and civilians caught in them have lives outside the storm of political turmoil, or at least dream of them. Why don’t games show a variety of these perspectives? And if players must take the roles of typical gruff white guy soldiers, why don’t games explore their lives before and after war, their reasons for enlisting, their hobbies, their vulnerabilities, their fears, hopes, and thoughts? Why don’t games go beyond the insights of Mass Effect 2’s loyalty missions or the recollection of Cole Train’s thrashball days in Gears of War 3? Why do so many soldiers in war games appear extraordinary, distanced from the civilians they might save?

Perhaps the answer lies in the distance between real soldiers and civilians and the barriers of communication between them. The cultural elevation of troops in the US forbids civilians from asking about their experiences out of respect, forcing veterans to hold in memories without being understood. Perhaps developers refrain from overly personal storytelling in war games out of respect and fear of misrepresenting soldiers’ personal experiences that civilian players “couldn’t possibly understand.” So instead they get not-even-close representations in action game fantasylands that end up playing it safe in their distance from intimate emotions and introspective storytelling.

In the article linked above, former Marine Phil Kay writes, “You don’t honor someone by telling them, ‘I can never imagine what you’ve been through.’ Instead, listen to their story and try to imagine being in it, no matter how hard or uncomfortable that feels.” What better way is there for civilians to “imagine being in it” than using interactive media? With care and nuance, video games could start chipping away that barrier between soldiers and civilians, delivering stories and experiences sometimes too difficult to articulate and too personal to ask about, which some games like Dys4ia are already doing.

And they should start by treating soldiers like human beings.